Significance and Use
4.1 Intended Use:
4.1.1 This guide may be used by various parties involved in sediment corrective action programs, including regulatory agencies, project sponsors, environmental consultants, toxicologists, risk assessors, site remediation professionals, environmental contractors, and other stakeholders.
4.2 Importance of the CSM:
4.2.1 The CSM should be updated as needed and refined to describe the physical properties, chemical composition and occurrence, biologic features, and environmental conditions of the sediment corrective action project (Guide E1689).
4.3 Reference Material:
4.3.1 This guide should be used in conjunction with other ASTM guides listed in 2.1 (especially Guides E3242 and E3382); this guide should also be used in conjunction with the material in the References at the end of this guide (including 1).3 Using these reference materials will direct the user in developing representative background concentrations for sediment at a sediment site.
4.4 Flexible Site-Specific Implementation:
4.4.1 This guide provides a systematic but flexible framework to accommodate variations in approaches by regulatory agencies and by the user based on project objectives, site complexity, unique site features, regulatory requirements, newly developed guidance, newly published scientific research, changes in regulatory criteria, advances in scientific knowledge and technical capability, and unforeseen circumstances.
4.5 Regulatory Frameworks:
4.5.1 This guide is intended to be applicable at a broad range of local, state, tribal, federal (such as CERCLA), or international jurisdictions, each with its own unique regulatory framework. As such, this guide does not provide a detailed discussion of the requirements or guidance associated with any of these regulatory frameworks, nor is it intended to supplant applicable regulations and guidance. The user of this guide will need to be aware of the regulatory requirements and guidance in the jurisdiction where the work is being performed.
4.5.2 Depending on the regulatory requirements in a jurisdiction, the choice of background reference areas may need to consider critical habitats and ecological receptors.
4.6 Systematic Project Planning and Scoping Process:
4.6.1 When applying this guide, the user should undertake a systematic project planning and scoping process to collect information to assist in making site-specific, user-defined decisions for a particular project, including assembling an experienced team of project professionals. These practitioners should have the appropriate expertise to scope, plan, and execute a sediment data acquisition and analysis program. This team may include, but is not limited to, project sponsors, environmental consultants, toxicologists, site remediation professionals, analytical chemists, geochemists, and statisticians.
4.7 Other Considerations:
4.7.1 This guide does not cover all components of a program to develop representative background concentrations for sediment. It is meant to be used in conjunction with other guides (such as Guides E3163, E3164, E3240, E3242, and E3382) to do so.
4.7.2 Sediment sampling and laboratory analyses are not covered in this guide. Guides E3163 and E3164 contain extensive information concerning sediment sampling and laboratory analyses.
4.7.3 Data quality objectives are not covered in this guide. Data quality objectives are described in (2).
4.7.4 Background study design considerations are not covered in this guide but are described in other references, including Guide E3163 and (3).
4.7.5 The use of data evaluation methodologies to obtain representative background data sets from candidate background data sets is not covered in detail in this guide but is discussed in more depth in Guide E3242.
4.7.5.1 Identification and removal of high nondetect values from candidate background data sets are discussed in detail in Guide E3242.
4.7.5.2 Identification and removal of outliers from candidate background data sets are discussed in detail in Practice E178, as well as Guide E3242.
4.7.5.3 Geochemical and chemical forensics methodologies used in evaluating candidate background data sets to obtain representative background data sets are discussed in detail in Guide E3242; their applications during background reference area selection are discussed in this guide.
4.7.6 The use of statistical methods to develop BTVs from representative background data sets are discussed in detail in Guide E3242.
4.7.7 The use of statistical methods to compare representative background data sets to sediment site data sets are discussed in detail in Guide E3242.
4.7.8 Geospatial analysis considerations are not thoroughly discussed in this guidance but are discussed in more depth relative to environmental evaluations in (4), which focuses on quality assurance concerns relative to geospatial analyses.
4.7.9 In this guide, sediment (3.1.15) is defined as material being found at the bottom of a water body. Upland soils of sedimentary origin are excluded from consideration as sediment in this guide.
4.7.10 In this guide, only PCOC concentrations are considered to be in scope. Residual background radioactivity is out of scope.
4.8 Structure and Components of this Guide:
4.8.1 The user of this guide should review the overall structure and components of this guide before proceeding with use, including:
| Section 1 | Scope |
| Section 2 | Referenced Documents |
| Section 3 | Terminology |
| Section 4 | Significance and Use |
| Section 5 | Overview of Representative Background Concentrations for Sediment at Sediment Sites and Development Framework |
| Section 6 | Background Reference Area Selection Criteria |
| Section 7 | Keywords |
| Appendix X1 | Case Study |
| References |
|
Scope
1.1 This guide focuses on the selection of sediment background reference areas from aquatic environments for the purpose of developing representative background concentrations for sediment at sediment sites. These concentrations are typically used in contaminated sediment corrective actions performed under various regulatory programs, including the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act (CERCLA). Although many of the references cited in this guide are CERCLA-oriented, the guide is applicable to remedial actions performed under local, state, tribal, federal, and international cleanup programs. However, this guide does not provide a detailed description of the existing background requirements or guidance for each jurisdiction. The requirements for the regulatory entity under which the corrective action is being performed should be reviewed to confirm compliance.
1.1.1 The sediment background reference areas chosen using this guide will need to be approved by the regulatory agency having jurisdiction (or they should take no exception to the areas chosen), especially if the representative background concentrations for sediment developed will potentially be used to set sediment remedial criteria.
1.2 This guide provides a framework to select appropriate sediment background reference areas for the collection of sediment data in the development of representative background concentrations for sediment at sediment sites. It is intended to inform, complement, and support (but not supersede) the requirements or guidelines established by local, state, tribal, federal, or international agencies.
1.2.1 This guide is designed to apply to contaminated sediment sites where sediment data have been collected and are readily available. Additionally, it assumes that risk assessments have been performed, so that the potential contaminants of concern (PCOCs) that exceed risk-based thresholds for sediment have been identified. This guide can be applied at multiple points within the project life cycle (such as site assessment and remedial design).
1.2.2 Furthermore, this guide presumes that the identified risk-based thresholds for sediment are low enough to pose corrective action implementation challenges or that the sediment site is subject to recontamination from ongoing anthropogenic or naturally occurring sources (or both) that are not controlled. In either case, representative background concentrations for sediment are useful for determining the extent of corrective remedial actions (when used as remedial goals), evaluating risks posed by these representative background concentrations, and establishing appropriate post-remedial monitoring plans.
1.2.3 A case study for selecting a background reference area using a tiered decision analysis approach is presented in Appendix X1. It compares various characteristics of a hypothetical sediment site associated with a former upland manufactured gas plant (MGP) facility to three candidate background reference areas and identifies the background reference area that best satisfies the decision analysis objectives in the choice of a single background reference area.
1.3 Related ASTM Standards—This guide is related several other guides. Guide E3382 provides the overarching framework for the development of representative background concentrations for sediment at contaminated sediment sites, including Conceptual Site Model (CSM) considerations. Guide E3242 describes how to evaluate candidate background data sets (including the use of statistical, geochemical, and chemical forensic methodologies) to obtain representative background data sets and then how to use these data sets to develop representative background concentrations for sediment. Guide E3164 covers the sampling methodologies used in the field to obtain sediment samples (whether from the sediment site or background reference areas), and Guide E3163 discusses appropriate laboratory methodologies to use for the chemical analysis of PCOCs in sediment samples. Guide D4823, which concerns sediment core sampling, is also related to this guide.
1.3.1 Specifically, this guide is intended to be used under the overarching framework of Guide E3382, in conjunction with the detailed framework to evaluate data and develop representative background concentrations for sediment outlined in Guide E3242, to help ensure appropriate background reference areas are chosen for use in representative background concentration development.
1.4 Units—The values stated in SI units are to be regarded as the standard. No other units of measurement are included in this guide.
1.5 This standard does not purport to address all of the safety concerns, if any, associated with its use. It is the responsibility of the user of this standard to establish appropriate safety, health, and environmental practices and determine the applicability of regulatory limitations prior to use.
1.6 This international standard was developed in accordance with internationally recognized principles on standardization established in the Decision on Principles for the Development of International Standards, Guides and Recommendations issued by the World Trade Organization Technical Barriers to Trade (TBT) Committee.
